爆料王

Opinion_

Vivid Sydney's future seems bright, but challenges abound

31 May 2024
Balancing spectacle with substance
Vivid Sydney is a globally recognised celebration of light, music and ideas, with each annual program delivering a bigger and brighter range of diverse content that continues to delight audiences. Yet the success of such a massive festival comes with challenges, writes Associate Professor Emrah Baki Ulas from the Sydney School of Architecture, Design and Planning.

It鈥檚 the year 2008, and some members of the International Association of Lighting Designers are gathered in a boardroom in North Sydney, myself included. My colleagues Mary-Anne Kyriakou (who would later be Vivid鈥檚 inaugural festival director) and Michael Day are sharing a vision of what鈥檚 almost unthinkable at the time.

They paint a picture of a light festival in which the winter of Sydney has become vibrant in colour: buildings are illuminated, streets are alive with creative light installations and the crowds walk about in awe. It is a vision that would soon become听.

This year鈥檚 program promises to impress once again with a diverse range of content including Julia Gutman鈥檚 first ever animation work,听, a story of wonder, vulnerability and strength displayed on the shells of the Sydney Opera House.

The Sydney Opera House shells show off the work Echo by Julia Gutman and Pleasant Company. Photo: Destination NSW.

Installations such as听听补苍诲听听by Sinclair Park touch on world issues in ways that offer both delight and prompt reflection.

We also see First Nations artist Tori-Jay Mordey鈥檚 work, Faces of Change, on the pylons of Sydney Harbour Bridge. It explores, among other themes, humanity鈥檚 connection to nature and the threat that rising sea levels pose to the Torres Strait Islands.

Artist Tori-Jay Mordey鈥檚 work, Faces of Change, will be projected onto the Sydney Harbour Bridge pylons. Photo: Destination NSW.

On the lighter side, there鈥檚 a听听you can have a rave on, and some听听held in a 100-year-old heritage substation.

It鈥檚 my hope Vivid Sydney will continue to captivate locals and visitors this year, and for the years to come. But while we look forward to these experiences, let鈥檚 also look at the challenges to overcome.

The Tekno Train experience by Paul Mac. Photo: Destination NSW.

When it all began

The inaugural听听event was staged in May 2009, laying the foundation for Vivid. The shells of the Sydney Opera House became a canvas for the festival鈥檚 first headline projection by Brian Eno.

Several small and large installations were staged across Circular Quay and the Rocks, with various landmark buildings lit up. A number of light artists and designers participated with passion, somewhat tight budgets, and relatively modest works compared to today鈥檚.

Smart Light Sydney offered glimpses of what could be possible in the future. Support from the government and private sector soon followed, and the stage was set for the future of Vivid.

Throughout the 2010s, Vivid inspired a number of smaller and听听in New South Wales and beyond to experiment with how lighting could become a spectacle and contribute to their own nightscapes.

In just a few years, Vivid evolved from a modest initiative into a听听celebration of light, music and ideas 鈥� positioning itself next to longer-running festivals such as Lyon鈥檚 famous听,听听and the Berlin听.

A balancing act

The success of such a massive festival will, of course, come with challenges. Vivid, for instance, must grapple with balancing genuine artistic endeavour with the objective of attracting the masses.

This is a fine and delicate balance. If tipped, Vivid could fall into the trap of prioritising spectacle over substance. Some critics听听that the festival emphasises grandiosity in a way that overshadows creative pursuit.

In recent years, the public and politicians have also criticised key light installations听, including this year鈥檚听听in the Botanic Gardens and听听in the Wynyard Tunnels.

The Wynyard Tunnels will be lit up as part of Dark Spectrum: A New Journey. Photo: Destination NSW.

Perhaps ticketing these offerings helps kerb visitor numbers so they can remain enjoyable (albeit for a smaller number of people). Or it may provide the revenue needed for the festival to deliver more innovative and valuable experiences.

Nonetheless, the decision has sparked听听over the commercialisation of what started as a cultural community event. Numerous corporate-sponsored installations have also now become centrepieces of the festival.

A spectator gets lost in the lamplight at Dark Spectrum: A New Journey. Photo: Destination NSW.

Beyond this is a growing challenge for creatives to build on what has already been done. The installations and projections this year again showcase great examples of what can be achieved through the creative use of light and technology. As the festival matures, however, people鈥檚 expectations also grow.

Festival-goers in front of the work Connection by New Zealand-based artist Angus Muir. Photo: Destination NSW.

Sustainability and logistical challenges

Environmental impact and听听are key considerations when thinking about Vivid鈥檚 future. The festival鈥檚 website details actions it has taken to deliver on this front, which have included partly offsetting its carbon footprint, using more renewable power, installing taps to reduce plastic landfill, encouraging public transport and going paper-free when possible.

Nonetheless, environmental issues remain intrinsic to an event of this scale. The festival鈥檚 light pollution and reliance on large-scale energy consumption are points of contention, especially as听听grows. Among all the environmental challenges the festival faces, using dark-sky friendly lighting is perhaps one of the most tricky.

Another challenge is that the festival鈥檚 growth has somewhat strained local infrastructure, leading to overcrowded public spaces and transport systems. During the festival weeks, portaloos, barricades and other temporary infrastructure also decorate the city.

While Vivid puts in a notable effort into remaining听听for all, the sheer number of attendees (supposedly听听last year) means听听this size comes with many hurdles.

Guan Wei's light installation听Sea, Sand and Stars soars across the听Museum of Contemporary Art facade. Photo: Destination NSW.

What the future may hold

These challenges aren鈥檛 unique to Vivid Sydney. They are faced by many similar events. In each context, there is nuance and also unique opportunities.

Vivid could play a profound, flagship role in showcasing Australia鈥檚 design culture to its own people and to the world. This is a culture characterised by kindness, fairness, diversity, creativity and a commitment to innovation and sustainability.

Perhaps Vivid鈥檚 future doesn鈥檛 rely on getting bigger and brighter, but on the finer aspects of its content. From embracing Indigenous wisdom, to connecting to nature, to highlighting world-class architecture and lighting design 鈥� Vivid has the potential to reinvent itself year on year.

But it will need to continue to deliver spectacle听with听subtlety to achieve this, and tell stories that touch people on a deeper level. Perhaps, unconventionally, it makes sense to embrace the darkness as much as the light.

Visitors get lost in the lights at Dark Spectrum: A New Journey. Photo: Destination NSW.


Dr Emrah Baki Ulas is an Associate Professor of Practice in the School of Architecture, Design and Planning at the 爆料王. He is an internationally established and acclaimed professional in the fields of lighting design, lighting masterplanning and daylighting. This story was first published on . Hero image:听Destination NSW.

The Conversation

Related Articles